| Heating for next winter-advice needed?

Heating for next winter-advice needed?

ed asked:

I just got a $724 bill for oil. The way the prices are going, a change needs to be made. My oil furnace is 20 years old, so it needs to go. My current options are:
1)Replace the oil furnace with a new more efficient one.
2)Convert to Natural Gas. The gas company is willing to install service up to the house for free. It would be my responsibility to have a contractor run a line from the house to the furnace and buy a new furnace.
3)Purchase and install a coal stove: I live in Central PA (coal region). 1 ton of coal is about $200. My buddy burned 3 tons this winter in his larger house.
4)Purchase and install a corn/wood pellet stove. Also, cheap in the area.
I would appreciate anyone with experience in this field’s opinion. No way I can afford to heat the house next winter if oil prices continue to rise. Thanks.
webs

Related posts:

  1. Heating for next winter-advice needed? ed asked: I just got a $724 bill for oil....
  2. Should I insulate or buy a outdoor wood stove? Amsiar asked: (Eventually I will do both but which should...

Filed Under Maintenance & Repairs |

Tagged With , ,

Comments

7 Responses to “Heating for next winter-advice needed?”

  1. donna d on April 10th, 2009 7:31 am

    i would go with the coal stove seems like the logical choice.

  2. dale on April 11th, 2009 12:17 pm

    you could also go electric heat i have electric heat and my light bill averages about $120 a month for everything including water heater

  3. tweety17112 on April 14th, 2009 5:31 am

    Go with the wood pellet stove. I have experienced this myself and it was wonderful. The stove fed itself about 10 pellets every half hour or so and it was nice and toasty. It is very easy to install and pretty darn cheap if you buy bulk (not bagged-way to expensive). I live in Central PA as well and we have been pricing them for a year now and do believe we will be getting one before this coming winter. There is a place in Carlisle that sells them at a decent price, I don’t remember right off the top of my head but it is on Simpson Ferry Road (I believe). Good luck with your decision.

  4. RICH @www.hvac-for-beginners.com on April 14th, 2009 9:57 am

    You have all those options and more. You could even get a CHP unit which produces electricity as a by product of heating. Check out all your options at

  5. What? Me Worry? on April 17th, 2009 7:56 am

    Investigate heat pumps. Air to air as well as water to air.

  6. racer_X on April 19th, 2009 10:55 am

    Get a new oil heating system. The new ones are usually about 20-30% more efficient than something that old. Depending on if you have baseboard or steam heat the prices will be very different. If its a hot water system with 1 zone your looking at about 5000 installed or if its steam about 6000. Also one more thing DO NOT have a plumber install it, have an oil company do it, in most states a plumbing license does not cover heating systems and plumbers dont know the state regulations. Another thing i see every other source of heat going up much higher than it is now too because the more ppl switch over the more expensive it will become.

  7. mobildik on April 21st, 2009 10:01 pm

    Your best choice would be Option 2. Obtain 3 proposals from local established HVAC companies. Oil burns and leaves your duct system dirty so locate a good Duct Cleaning company. Have the ducts and return airs cleaned prior to installing the new furnace.
    Natural Gas furnaces are available in: A. single stage units. B. 2-stage units. C. 2 stage with variable speed blowers. Good manufacturers include American Standard, Trane, Amana, Rheem, Carrier, Tempstar, Lennox. Stay away from Janitrol and Goodman furnaces.
    A Good HVAC company knows how to do heat/cool load calculations to determine the proper sized equipment for the house. Bigger is not necessarily better!
    Coal also burns dirty and corn stoves easily get clogged due to the high sugar content in corn. Good hardwood pellets such as oak are becoming expensive also.
    As you can tell, my recommendation’s are gas forced air furnaces.
    Good Luck!